Archive Feature

Fact or Fiction?


By Dr. Michael Kelly
  Notes  
  1 Ward E.W. and Hughes T.E., “Sudden Death Following Chest Tube Insertion: An Unusual Case of Vagus Nerve Irritation,” Journal of Trauma, February 1994, 36 (2): 258- 259.

2 Adams D., Victor M. and Ropper A.H., Principles of Neurology, 6th ed., 1997, 546.

3 Martin R., Jorgensen J.E., Clark D. and Bredenberg C., “Blunt Trauma to the Carotid Arteries,” Journal of Vascular Surgery, 1991, 14 (6): 789-795.

4 An T.L., “Fatal Thrombosis of Internal Carotid Artery Following Minor Blunt Trauma to the Neck,” Journal of Forensic Science, May 1989, 34 (3): 699-702.

5 McCarron M.O., Patterson J. and Duncan R., “Stroke Without Dissection from a Neck Holding Maneuver in Martial Arts,” British Journal of Sports Medicine, December 1997, 31(4): 346-347.

6 Carr S., Troop B., Hurley J. and Pennell R., “Blunt Trauma Carotid Artery Injury: Mild Symptoms May Disguise Serious Trouble,” The Physician and Sports Medicine, February 1996, 24 (2): 10-16.

7 Martin R., et al., 789-795.

8 Fakhry S.M., Jaques P.F. and Proctor H.J., “Cervical Vessel Injury After Blunt Trauma,” Journal of Vascular Surgery, October 1988, 8 (4): 501.

9 Kraus R., Bergstein J. and Debord J., “Diagnosis, Treatment and Outcome of Blunt Carotid Arterial Injuries,” The American Journal of Surgery, September 1999, 178: 191.

10 An T.L., 699-702.

11 Li M., Smith B., Espinosa J., Brown R., Richardson P. and Ford R., “Nonpenetrating Trauma to the Carotid Artery: Seven Cases and a Literature Review,” The Journal of Trauma, February 1994, 36(2): 268.

12 Blumenthal D.T., Riggs J.E. and Ortiz O., “Carotid Artery Occlusion Following a Karate Punch to the Neck,” Military Medicine, September 1996, 161 (9): 562-563.

13 Li M. et al., 267.

14 Shima, Nishida, Yamane and Kagawa, “Traumatic Dissection of the Common Carotid Artery After Blunt Injury to the Neck,” Surgical Neurology, May 1999, 51 (5): 519-520.

15 McCarron M.O. et al., 346-347.

16 Meairs S., Timpe L. and Beyer J., “Acute Aphasia and Hemiplegia During Karate Training,” The Lancet, July 2000, 356:40.

17 Meairs S. et al., 340.

18 David G.G. and Glass J.M., “Case Report of Sudden Death After a Blow to the Back of the Neck,” American Journal of Forensic Medical Pathology, March 2001, 22 (1): 13-8.

19 Ogata M., Ago K., Ago M. and Tsuganezawa O., “A Case of Death Due to Neurogenic Shock,” Nippon Hoigaku Zasshi, April 1992, 46 (2): 152-158.

20 Wilkerson L., “Martial Arts Injuries,” Journal of the American Osteopathic Association, April 1997, 97 (4): 221-226.

21 Kohl P., Nesbitt A.D., Cooper P.J. and Ming L., “Sudden Cardiac Death by Commotio Cordis: The Role of Mechano-Electric Feedback,” Cardiovascular Research, December 2000, 50 (2001): 280-289.

22 Link M.S., Maron B.J., Vanderbrink B.A., Takeushi M., Pandian N.G., Wang P.J. and Estes N.A., “Impact Directly Over the Cardiac Silhouette Is Necessary to Produce Ventricular Fibrillation in an Experimental Model of Commotio Cordis,” Journal of the American College of Cardiology, February 2001, 37 (2): 649-654.

23 Maron B.J., Poliac L.C., Kaplan J.A. and Mueller F.O., “Blunt Impact to the Chest Leading to Sudden Death From Cardiac Arrest During Sports Activities,” New England Journal of Medicine, August 1995, Vol. 333, No. 6, 338.

24 Denton J.S. and Kalelkar M.B., “Homicidal Commotio Cordis in Two Children,” Journal of Forensic Science, May 2000, 45 (3), 734-735.

25 Wilkerson L., 225.

26 Link M.S. et al., 649-654.

By Any Other Name
Chi is a Chinese word that is often equated with “internal energy,” but it is better to not translate it because no English word can accurately describe its meaning. Martial artists should stick with the language of their art’s country of origin: chi for Chinese stylists, ki for Japanese and Korean stylists, and prana for practitioners of Indian yoga.

Irrespective of how it is written or pronounced, its meaning and essence transcend borders and cultures. It is universally recognized as the essential ingredient of life. In the martial and healing arts, it is known for what it does rather than what it is. It plays a pivotal role in sustaining health and happiness and preventing disease and death.

Chinese medicine holds that energization of the blood by chi is a powerful biological life force. In self-healing, chi is moved through all the body’s meridians to ensure that it is neither blocked nor stagnated. Movement and exercise—particularly specialized exercises such as those of tai chi, dao yin, chi kung, and some styles of kung fu and self-massage—are designed to promote the smooth flow of chi. —Dr. Pier Tsui-Po

Dim Mak in Defense
In a self-defense situation, dim mak can be used to impede or stop the body’s chi flow. The vital point or combination of points the martial artist activates depends on the particular aspect of the attacker’s chi he wants to affect. The dim mak technique may: • Alter the natural flow of chi through the meridian system.

• Damage the supply of chi to the internal organs and damage the organs themselves, including their functions.

• Damage the aspect of chi that controls all movement in the body.

• Disrupt the protective function of wei (stomach) chi over the entire body.

• Disrupt the transformation of food, water and fluids in the body.

• Damage the holding and retention function of chi so the body’s substances and organs cannot be held in their proper place.

• Damage chi sufficiently so it stops warming the body.

—Dr. Pier Tsui-Po

Heart-Stopper
Striking certain dim mak points can result in serious injury, immediate death or delayed death. Consider the conception vessel point 17 (CV-17).

Also known as shan zhong, it influences chi flow, the respiratory system and breathing. It also regulates lung function and the upper heater. When you are in good health, it expands and relaxes your chest, diffuses lung chi and transforms phlegm. It also warms yang due to its connection with the kidney, pericardium, small intestine, three heater and the meridians.

Injury to CV-17 can stop the circulation of heart chi and lung chi. A sharp blow to it can damage the material basis of this energy. When it is hit, two separate sets of symptoms will occur.

One will reflect a direct injury to the pressure point, and the other will depend on whether the meridian itself has been struck with a counter-flow technique.

Since the point is directly over the heart, striking it may fracture the sternum and damage the heart and lungs, impairing the function of these organs and causing cardiac temponade and pneumothorax. Immediate symptoms can include shortness of breath, chest pain, labored breathing, facial pallor and diaphragmatic spasms. Palpitations, pain, anxiety and inability to speak are also experienced because this point is the “master alarm point” of the pericardium, which protects the heart.

Anyone who is forcefully struck at CV-17 should seek immediate medical attention because death can result. Even if death does not occur, the shortand long-term impact on the mind and body will be serious if the imbalance of chi is not corrected.

—Dr. Pier Tsui-Po

 
Medical Science Examines Dim Mak and Its Infamous Death Touch

   
Although practitioners often argue over the validity of pressure-point strikes, medical literature is filled with instances in which certain martial arts strikes have resulted in unexpectedly serious injury. (For illustrative purposes, Cung Le is shown delivering a knee thrust to the abdomen of Rudi Ott.)
   
Little force is needed to affect the carotid artery, the author says. In one case study, a middle-aged man was partially paralyzed after his neck was squeezed. (For illustrative purposes, Willie Johnson is shown controlling Marco Johnson.)
   
Whether intentional or accidental, a punch to the neck can injure the carotid artery. In fact, one man who sustained such a blow later suffered a stroke.
   
Upper: The stomach-9 point. Lower: The bladder-10 point. Care should be taken during practice because striking either one can lead to serious health problems or even death, the author says.
   
Nothing polarizes the martial arts world like dim mak. Whether you use its Chinese name, its Japanese name (kyusho-jutsu) or its American name (pressure-point fighting), the result the same: People who practice the controversial combat method affirm the effectiveness of their techniques, which concentrate on attacking vulnerable areas of the body through acupuncture points, and claim their art is an invaluable link to the fighting skills of the past. Meanwhile, critics insist that dim mak points either do not exist or are ineffective in combat. They base their arguments on the assumption that there are no documented cases of injuries from blows delivered to the points, either accidentally or intentionally, during combat.

In reality, the arguments that decry the effectiveness of dim mak are based on misinformation. Modern medical literature contains numerous articles and case studies that provide evidence that attacking the body’s vital points can result in serious injury and that such injuries can occur during real confrontations.

Pressure Cooker
Located directly over the location at which the carotid artery bifurcates into the internal and external carotid arteries, the stomach-9 point is reputed to be able to cause knockout, death and delayed death. This part of the artery contains a special sensory organ, the carotid sinus, which monitors the pressure of the blood that flows to the brain.

When the pressure is too high, it signals the vasomotor center in the brain to decrease the blood pressure by dilating the peripheral blood vessels and decreasing the heart rate. Physicians routinely exploit the hear t - rate-lowering effect of carotid sinus stimulation to stop certain abnormal heart rhythms. However, medical science has found that excessive stimulation of this organ causes a drastic decrease in blood pressure that can lead to loss of consciousness or even cardiac arrest. 1, 2 Additionally, the carotid arteries are prone to a buildup of atherosclerotic plaques in the carotid sinus.

Blows to the carotid sinus via stomach- 9 can damage or cause small tears on the inside of the carotid artery, which can cause blood clots leading to occlusion and subsequent stroke or death. 3, 4 Medical science has found that the plaques develop during childhood, so even young people are at some risk, albeit small, if a blow breaks off a piece of plaque which then travels to the brain.

Some martial artists protest that stomach-9 is not really dangerous because there are no documented cases in which people were seriously injured from accidental or intentional blows to the carotid sinus or carotid artery.

However, an abundance of medical literature describes serious injuries that resulted from blunt carotid artery trauma, including fainting, stroke and death. 5, 6, 7 In fact, 80 percent of blunt carotid artery injuries result in death or severe neurological impairment.

8 There are even cases in which direct blows to the carotid artery (stomach-9 point) resulted in a stroke or death. 9, 10, 11 The most dramatic example involves a young man who received a punch to the carotid artery during a karate class. He suffered a stroke and developed weakness on one side of his body one week later, secondary to occlusion of the carotid artery. 12 It is not surprising that these symptoms were delayed because it is well-known that such trauma can cause delayed neurological deficits or death. 13 Another study showed that these deficits could occur up to 10 years later. 14 Perhaps this phenomenon is the etiology of the legendary “delayed death touch.”

Although some practitioners assume that a great deal of force is required for such damage to occur, evidence indicates that merely grabbing the carotid artery can lead to a stroke or death. 15, 16 In one documented case, a middle-aged karate expert developed sudden hemi paresis and was unable to speak after his carotid artery was grabbed during a practice session. 17

Sudden Death
Located on the back of the neck at the base of the skull, the bladder-10 point is considered one of the most lethal dim mak points. This may seem outrageous to critics, but there is a documented case of a man who died suddenly after receiving a blow to this location. 18 Although it was at first suspected that brain trauma was the cause of death, an autopsy showed only blunt trauma in the area of bladder-10. The mechanism of death was believed to have involved stimulation of the occipital nerves leading to dysfunction of the autonomic nervous system.

There are also many reports of sudden death resulting from low-energy impacts to the chest. The autopsy of a homicide victim—a young man who died after receiving blows to his chest, abdomen and solar plexus—showed no external or internal signs of injury.

Consequently, his death was attributed to dysfunction of the autonomic nervous system secondary to the solar plexus blows. 19 Another young martial artist suddenly died after he was kicked in the solar plexus during a sparring match. 20 Such cases of commotio cordis, which is Latin for “heart concussion,” have been published for more than 120 years. 21 Although many instances of this phenomenon involve baseballs and hockey pucks, a number of cases have occurred during street fights and karate practice sessions. 22, 23, 24 One young martial artist suddenly died after being kicked in the chest, 25 and the bruises on the chests of many other victims correlate with these points. In addition, the areas where blows are most likely to induce commotio cordis correlate with the exact location of lethal dim mak points. 26 Hypotheses These examples illustrate how modern medical science can be used to prove that there are areas on the human body that can cause death or illness when attacked and that these areas correlate with the location of dim mak points. Although the cited cases do not attribute the injuries to fluctuations in chi (internal energy), they still provide evidence that there are vulnerable areas of the body that can be exploited during combat. The only question that remains is, By what mechanism do such injuries occur?

The traditional explanations involve disturbances in chi, but these are difficult concepts to prove and thus are dismissed by many as nonsense. However, we should not doubt the existence of a phenomenon just because we question the validity of its explanation. Throughout history, many popular theories have been replaced with improved ones as science has advanced. If the answer to a poor explanation was simply to dismiss the phenomenon as nonexistent, we would never have achieved the technological advances we now take for granted.

Perhaps we can extrapolate from history that it is now time for the older, esoteric explanations of dim mak to be replaced with more modern medical explanations.

Dr. Michael Kelly has trained in the martial arts for more than 17 years. He has extensively studied the medical science behind dim mak and has written numerous articles on the subject, as well as a book titled Death Touch: The Science Behind the Legend of Dim Mak. For more information, send e-mail to Dr.Kelly@dimmak.net or visit www.dimmak.net.

 
Get a FREE TRIAL ISSUE of Black Belt





If I like Black Belt I'll pay $29 for a full year (12 issues). If I'm not satisfied, I'll return the bill marked "cancel" and owe nothing. The cancellation is effective immediately and any trial issues I receive are mine to keep free.

Terms of agreement

Advertisement

Online Store

Find All the Martial Arts
Products You Need
Featured Item...
Kapap: Combat Concepts >>

E-Newsletter

Breaking news, updates and more

Dojo Directory

Find Dojos by State/Province or Country

Classifieds

Find items by category

Advertisement

B.J. Penn - MMA Techniques

In Their Own Words

B.J. Penn - MMA Techniques

PLAY AUDIO

Forums

Connect with Black Belt readers! Voice your opinion on a variety of martial arts topics!